Reporting Renewed vs. New Subscriptions in Analytics

Hi Friends,

We are still fairly new to Analytics. Does anyone have a dashboard they could share with me that reports on renewed vs. new subscription packages? Currently in my dashboard I use list to filter renewals vs. new subscriptions, but I am noticing the lists are not pulling in all of the sales resulting in our an understatement of our total. In other words the lists I am using are not correct, but I have tried almost everything to correct them with no luck. When I toggle the filter to enable and disable the lists I am off by almost $100K. 

Instead of filtering by lists has anyone been able to use a different filter to report on renewals vs new subscribers?

I appreciate any insight or guidance.

Thank You!

-Dan