Serious Rollover Issues and can't figure it out.

Hey guys. 

I am one of the lucky people that has to rollover over their last season's packages into dummy performances. So I've built the performances for each package that we offer. I have created the sets.  Do I need to attach my list of current subscribers? 

The set up is like this:

The error I'm getting in the rollover manager says: 

Error finding Source/Appeal...

I changed the Appeal and Source to leave blank.