Hi Lou,
We were in the exact same place as you a few months ago. We decided to put EMV readers in our box office for specific transactions. Since we really only need to save cards for donors and subscribers, we've set in place business rules for out ticket sellers. Any single ticket purchases go through the EMV readers, any subscription purchases they type the card number in the Tessitura payments window. Our gifts processor doesn't use a card reader at all.
Eventually we will go to tokenization for the donor and subscriber cards we are saving, but at the moment there's some work on our custom website that needs to happen first. We're also waiting on v.14 because it seems that the payment updates may integrate with tokenization a little better.
Hope this helps,
Dorothy
Thanks for everyone's replies. Greg Stickney from support reached out to me and clarified my confusion. Enrypted devices can be used to enter a credit card which can be converted to a token and stored on the constituent's record. We will go that route for our recurring payments. We can have encryption and recurring payments! That is what I wanted to hear.