Best Practice for Zip Code Criteria

I'm trying to set up a few lists for my team to be able to pull donors in a certain zip code and am struggling with the appropriate way to truly include everyone in those zip codes. We store both the standard five and five plus four zips in our instance of Tessitura and when I choose the criteria of Like with the 5 digit zip code it seems to skip anyone with the plus four. When I add the wild card indicator to the end of the 5 digits I'm looking for it includes anyone with those five digits in a row. Any advice?
Parents Reply Children