Constituents appearing twice in dashboard (and they shouldn't be)

Hi friends!

I'm hoping you might be able to help my solve my issue before I open a TASK ticket.  We've created a few dashboards to report on our subscription revenue, broken out by renewals and acquisitions.  However, for one specific widget, it looks like some constituents are showing up twice, in two separate categories. See screenshot.

I checked their order and they only have one source, which points to our Subscription - Renewal appeal category, so I'm puzzled as to why they are showing up in the acquisition category as well.  Has this happened to anyone else and is there a way to solve?

Thanks in advance!  I'm happy to provide more detail if needed!