New Analytics User Group Sharing

Hello hive mind,

I have created a new user group that only has access to analytics. I triple checked the division and control groups assigned to this user group and they are correct. I've also ensured that the 5 security objects for analytics are added to this new user group. When I log in as that user group, I see the group and am able to share to it (probably because I am also System Admin...but not logged in as that). The other users I have in this group can log into the user group and open analytics just fine. However, they do not see the analytics user group...that they are logged in as. All they see is their other user groups.

Any advice?

- Chris