Pulling a list using a contribution source code

Former Member
Former Member $organization

I'm trying to pull a list of all of our constituents who have renewed their Memberships with us, and are entitled to a free Tote Bag.

All of these constituents, when I was processing their contributions, were given the source number 36.

I've tried compiling a list of these constituents via List Manager, selecting "Contribution Source Number" = 36 as a Criteria for the list, however it pulls no results.

As a Tess newbie, should this be done in a different way? Perhaps through Campaigns or Appeals?